SWFC v PNE Player ratings

Im crap at this but obviously @Emerson Thome is busy today so here is the ratings thread.

We were excellent first half and not all that shabby in the second. How we’ve lost that game is absolutely bonkers as we were by far the better side. Our lack of height at set plays has killed us this season.

Horvath 5 two good saves ruined by their second and third goals. He’s just not very good. Hopefully Charles back next week

Fusire 5.5 he’s struggled in the last few games for me. He’s got something but he’s not a CM and I’m not sure he’s a wing back either

Valery 7 slotted in very well to CB. Very good versatile player

Otegbayo 6.5 one of his better performances. Still scares the life out of me when the ball is at his feet

Palmer 8 I thought he was excellent. Great cross for the second and some driving runs

Amass 6 one of his quieter games. Probably knackered 

Ingelsson 7.5 thought he was very good in the holding 6 role. Much better than his usual run and foul play on the wing. Keep him there

Bannan 8 was excellent. Played almost as a number 10 first half. Too deep late on

J. Lowe 7.5 played very intelligently with Bannan. Often swooped positions and found himself in midfield a lot. Very good

McNeill 7.5 I’d like to go higher as he scored two great goals but his penalty was crap. Why on earth was he allowed to take it?

Cadamarteri 4 I’m sorry but he’s just not very good. No other striker in this league misses that one on one (OK maybe Ugbo…lol). Desperately need a striker in January  

Cooper 7 we look so much better with him on the pitch. A real leader

Redmond 6 looked bright. Chose the wrong option at times but at least he can run with the ball

Pedersen 6 interesting set up worked but practice set plays in training !!!

Ref 3 abysmal. He missed a definite handball that was much easier to catch than the one he saw. Also, why was their full back not sent off for a second yellow after the penalty decision. Shocking decisions that along with our inability to defend set plays, cost us the game!

5 minutes ago, Owlabroad2001 said:

Im crap at this but obviously @Emerson Thome is busy today so here is the ratings thread.

 

We were excellent first half and not all that shabby in the second. How we’ve lost that game is absolutely bonkers as we were by far the better side. Our lack of height at set plays has killed us this season.

 

Horvath 5 two good saves ruined by their second and third goals. He’s just not very good. Hopefully Charles back next week

Fusire 5.5 he’s struggled in the last few games for me. He’s got something but he’s not a CM and I’m not sure he’s a wing back either

Valery 7 slotted in very well to CB. Very good versatile player

Otegbayo 6.5 one of his better performances. Still scares the life out of me when the ball is at his feet

Palmer 8 I thought he was excellent. Great cross for the second and some driving runs

Amass 6 one of his quieter games. Probably knackered 

Ingelsson 7.5 thought he was very good in the holding 6 role. Much better than his usual run and foul play on the wing. Keep him there

Bannan 8 was excellent. Played almost as a number 10 first half. Too deep late on

J. Lowe 7.5 played very intelligently with Bannan. Often swooped positions and found himself in midfield a lot. Very good

McNeill 7.5 I’d like to go higher as he scored two great goals but his penalty was crap. Why on earth was he allowed to take it?

Cadamarteri 4 I’m sorry but he’s just not very good. No other striker in this league misses that one on one (OK maybe Ugbo…lol). Desperately need a striker in January  

 

Cooper 7 we look so much better with him on the pitch. A real leader

Redmond 6 looked bright. Chose the wrong option at times but at least he can run with the ball

 

Pedersen 6 interesting set up worked but practice set plays in training !!!

 

Ref 3 abysmal. He missed a definite handball that was much easier to catch than the one he saw. Also, why was their full back not sent off for a second yellow after the penalty decision. Shocking decisions that along with our inability to defend set plays, cost us the game!

Agree, blatant handball preventing goal should have been straght red for the first one he missed, then easily a second yellow for handball in the area.  Why do refs bottle it when they know the rules?

Horvath    -    6    -    Couple of decent saves but poor for second goal

Valery    -    7    -    Played well , think DR may well try to tempt away in January.

Otegbayo    -    5    -    Overall a little better than previous but awful for second goal, leaves his man to chase ball, gets nowhere near it and then sees the man he left have a simple nod in.

Palmer    -    7    -    Much better than last week.

Fusire     -    5    -    Thought he struggled for the most part.

Ingelsson    -    7    -     Been crying out for months to play him deeper and he looked better for it.

Bannan    -    8    -    Back to controlling things, impressive performance.

Amass    -    7    -    Excellent first half but faded second due to us having to play him every game I would think.

J.Lowe    -    7    -    Some really good link up play yesterday but sadly still offered no goal threat.

Cadamarteri    -    5    -    As much as we all wish it were so I don`t think he has the skillset to make it at this level.  Physically strong and no problem with his endeavour, but his first touch is quite often poor and his reading of the game/ positioning is lacking also....for once we had several excellent crosses flashed across the box and as main striker he should have been in there but was stood outside the area.  He is coming up to 21 now so there is still time to improve and i really hope he does as he seems a genuine lad but atm he looks more suited to league 1/2 and maybe in an ideal world that`s where he would be on loan.

McNeill    -    7.5    -    His career in a nutshell.  it was clear from little flashes here and there that the lad has ability and in the first 45 mins it was there for all to see, as well as workrate and desire.   Second half saw him slip back to some sloppy passing and drifting out of the game as well as a poor penalty.   The challenge for the lad is to make that first half the norm not the exception.

Cooper    -    7    -    Looked more solid straight away

Redmond    -    6.5    A few nice moments.

Much, much better but our weak and soft underbelly does for us time and again.

8 hours ago, Owlabroad2001 said:

Cadamarteri 4 I’m sorry but he’s just not very good. No other striker in this league misses that one on one

Literally saw Josh Sargeant miss a very similar one for Norwich at Hillsborough about 2-3 weeks a go. He’s one of best strikers in league. 
 

He should’ve scored, he’ll know that better than anyone, but it happens.

Horvath - 6 

Valery - 6.5

Otegbayo - 6

Palmer - 7 

Fusire - 6

Ingelsson - 6

Bannan - 7

Amass - 7 

J.Lowe - 6

Cadamarteri - 5 

McNeill - 7.5 

Cooper - 6

Redmond - 6.5